Mix Up an Award-Winning Ice Cream Creation!

MaggieMoo's super premium ice cream is made fresh in the Treatery. You can create your own ice cream masterpiece by selecting one of our award-winning ice cream flavors and choosing your favorite mix-ins, such as nuts, fruits and candy. We handfold your creation right in front of you.

Start creating with our list of flavors and mix-ins below! Some flavors and mix-ins are subject to seasonal availability and may vary by Treatery location. Or, try one of Maggie's Fresh Escapes, fifteen of her favorite ice cream combinations.

Ice Cream Flavors Amooretto™ Apple Strudel Banana Pudding Better Batter™ Black Cherry Blueberry Muffin Butter Pecan Buttered Popcorn Cafe Cubana Carrot Cake Cheesecake Cinnamoo Bun Cocoa Amooretto Cotton Candy Chocolate Chocolate Banana Chocolate Better Batter Choco-Mallo™ Chocolate Peanut Butter Chocolate Raspberry Cinnamoo™ Cool Mint Creamy Coconut Dark Chocolate Egg Nog Espresso Bean French Vanilla Fresh Banana Irish Cream Key Lime Maggie's Fudge™ Mint Chocolate Moocha™ Low Fat, Lactose Free Vanilla Peanut Butter with Reese's Peanut Butter Pina Cowlada™ Pink Bubblegum Pink Peppermint Stick Pistachio Pumpkin Pie Raspberry Red Velvet Strawberry Southern Peaches Udderly Cream™ Vanilla Vanilla Bean Very Yellow Marshmallow™ No-Sugar Added Banana-Strawberry

Mix-Ins Almonds Bananas Brownies Butterfingers® Cherries Chocolate Flakes Chocolate Sprinkles Coconut Cookie Dough Gummy Bears Heath Bar® Kit Kat® M&M's® Mini Marshmallows Mixed Nuts Mounds® Oreo's® Pecans Pineapple Rainbow Sprinkles Raspberries Reese's® Pieces Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups Snickers® Snow Caps® Strawberries Teddy Grahams Twix® Walnuts White Chocolate Chips York Peppermint Patties®